What I wrote at Lib Dem Voice

July 26, 2007

The Harry Potter subtext debate

There’s a fascinating debate raging among Lib Dem bloggers (where else?) regarding the seeming absence of gay characters in the Harry Potter books; and whether it matters a damn.

It was prompted by the Clowns to the Left of Me blog posting, ‘Why aren’t there any gay characters in Harry Potter?’ (I assume the question refers to the book, rather than to the character, or else I missed a scandalous passage.) This question was then somewhat unfairly scorned by the Norfolk Blogger, before being further analysed at Hunting for Witches.

Alex Wilcock has pointed out in a comment, correctly, that there is a gay character in the Harry Potter series: Remus Lupin is clearly portrayed as gay in the third book, Prisoner of Azkaban - which is why, at the end, he has to leave Hogwarts, when the school’s parents discover his secret.

The trait was picked up by the film adaptation in which David Thewlis’s Lupin is shown indulging his love of musicals. And if you think I’m over-exaggerating the homoerotic overtones, watch this, and you’ll see I’m not the only one:




So, why didn’t JK follow through this line of characterisation? Two possibilities occur:

(i) she was totally oblivious, and I (and others) have read way too much subtext; or

(ii) she (or her publisher) decided it was too risque for such a popular kids' book.

There's also another possibility. That Lupin is differentis clearly part of the book. However, there’s an uncomfortable analogy which JK may have decided, on reflection, she was better not pursuing: Lupin is ‘different’ because, against his wishes, he is turned into a werewolf having been preyed on by a predator. He then finds himself unable to control his own actions when he becomes a werewolf, and is a threat to others, even his closest friends. Indeed, he has to be confined when the moon is full. JK may have felt that drawing comparisons between Lupin’s latent homosexuality and his werewolf status would simply have re-inforced negative stereotypes. As it is, JK's heart doesn't really seem to be in it when she marries off Lupin and Tonks, a union which always appeared mis-matched.

This is even more reason if you consider the evil Fenric Greyback, another werewolf, who makes it his life’s mission deliberately to go round infecting healthy wizards to turn them into werewolves. (Greyback/Bareback, anyone?)

By the way, any female reader of Harry Potter would be far more likely to dwell on the lack of positive powerful female role models. There’s Hermione, but she’s a swot. Other than that, the major characters - Harry, Voldemort, Dumbledore and Snape - are all male. An argument can be made for McGonagall, but she is always Dumbledore’s deputy, his support, who defers to him. Mrs Weasley is the archetypal Mother Earth figure. And the two great wizard houses of Hogwarts founders are Gryffindor and Slytherin, again both male. Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff, the two female founders’ houses, are also-rans. The wizarding world, it seems, is just as male-dominated as the real world.

Who said these books were fantasy?

26 comments:

Anonymous said...

I compared the werewolfs to a discriminated ethnic minority, not to a discriminated sexual minority.

But I think that Luna Lovegood might have been a lesbian, though.

simon said...

No poofs in Potter? Who cares! I'll stick to 'The Authority' where we see 'Apollo' and 'The Midnighter' (comic's first gay couple) regularly kicking the living crap out of the baddies! What fun!

Anonymous said...

Poofs? How liberal, indeed.

Norfolk Blogger said...

A really grown up assessment and analysis, and far more educated than me on the subject, as ever.

I could have put my arguments more lucidly, but given my tiredness, I failed.

The point I was trying to make is that every minority group can complain about something. Why has there been no black James Bond ? Why are there no Migrant workers in Coronations Street ? Why no asians in Emerdale ? Indeed, why are there no positive role models of people with country accents (West Country, East Anglia) in any TV dramas ?

We could all get angry, or in the case of someone on my blog get personally aggressive and call people names. But the point is that in a book which is a piece of fantasy, as in TV which is NOT a reality programme, it does not have to reflect society as a whole.

Anonymous said...

Who decides which books get press (Harry Potter) and which get censored? After all, censorship is becoming America's favorite past-time. The US gov't (and their corporate friends), already detain protesters, ban books like "America Deceived" from Amazon and Wikipedia, shut down Imus and fire 21-year tenured, BYU physics professor Steven Jones because he proved explosives, thermite in particular, took down the WTC buildings. Free Speech forever (especially for books).
Last link (before Google Books caves to pressure and drops the title):
America Deceived (book)

Boxwatcher said...

Isn't there a Polish woman in the knicker sweat shop in Coronation Street? There was a story a few months ago when another migrant worker was killed falling down stairs. The management tried to cover up that she'd been working double shifts.

Lauren said...

There's also Sirius Black, who, it appears, may have, at one time at least, been in a relationship with Remus. Prisoner of Azkaban has quite a lot of subtext along with the repeated line "together?" "I think so" and in book five, during Snape's worst Memory, Sirius is completely failing to notice the trail of girls staring at him in order to simply look at Remus reading.

Sirius is a daredevil, attention seeking and deeply loyal man, who, to quote Rowling "never bothered having a girlfriend" and was disowned from the Anicient and Most Noble House of Black for disgracing the family name... Hmmm...

There are some arguments that Remus' Lycanthropy is an analogy for HIV, also (with Fenrir some sort of bareback paedophile), but i agree that Remus' insistence at the end of Prsoner of Azkaban that the parents would want the children to be taught "by someone like me" do have deep echoes in homophobia.

I also agree that his Marriage to Tonks was sketched extremely thinly, and it's interesting that we never see them both happy at the same time, and the sidelining of her character in the final book was deeply disappointing.

Could it be, that in Remus Lupin, we have one of the first, strong and deeply likeable Bisexual characters?

Maybe that's too much to hope for...

Jesse said...

I agree, that as a female reader I prefer to obsess over the lack of interesting female characters which aren't all reduced to one stereotype. For example Hermione is often compared to Petunia Dursley or Mrs. Weasley, as though all women are alike.
However I too would have liked one two of the characters to be outed. Lupin for one, although that seems impossible now.

James Graham said...

Coming to this late, I know, but I have to say that there is a very strong sexual tension between Harry and Draco Malfoy. I'm not saying they actually had a fumble in the Room of Requirement, but it is clear they both have a lot of repressed feelings for each other.

Harry's 'love' of Ginny Weasley is also ambiguous at best - look at the way he not only ditches her at the end of book 6 but only seems to ever express his desire for her in idealised romantic terms. It's never visceral. That may be a failing on the part of the author, but what is odd is the way he brushes past her after the finale in book 7, preferring the company of dead headmasters. What?!

Finally, there is that final scene, years later, when they bump into Malfoy at Kings Cross, replete with forlorn glances. The scenes of Hogsmeade station were filmed at the same station (Carnforth) as the one used for Brief Encounter. Do I have to paint you a picture?

Anonymous said...

msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
şekilli msn nickleri
şekilli nickler
güzel msn nickleri
frmtr
msn nickleri
.
.
.

wp themes
blogger templates
wordpress temaları
wordpress themes
wp themes
wordpress temaları
blogger templates
wp themes
blogger themes
blogger templates


erken rezervasyon
129.93.251.82
free link directory
e-directorylive
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
test atölyesi
testatölyesi
test atölyesi
testatölyesi
Msn Nickleri
free warez
Msn avatarları
free wordpress templates
free wordpress themes
free wp themes
free wp themes
free wp templates
blogger tips template
blogger template
blogger themes
free blogger templates
free blogger themes
wordpress templates
blogger templates

sandbox
msn nickleri
webmaster
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
dmoz
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
msn nickleri
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması

dmoz
alexa
kaiser_dealxa
seo uzmanı
seo
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması



msn nickleri
msn nickleri
freewaresmania
msn nickleri
msn
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
todd livingston
aşk şiirleri
aşk şiirleri
haberler
msn nickleri
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
e-okul
health articles
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
credito
pret
msn nicknames
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
hilary duff
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon
ramazan ayı
msn nickleri
msn spitznamen
msn nickleri
hayal bahçesi
şarkı sözleri
seo yarışması
msn nickleri
gafoloji
msn nickleri
msn nickleri


msn nickleri
tsubasa
ev dekorasyon

msn nickleri

yeni msn nickleri

msn avatarları

komik msn nickleri

delikanlı msn nickleri

güzel msn avatarları

şekilli msn nickleri

msn avatarları

beşiktaş nickleri
aşk sevgi nickleri
duygusal msn nickleri
damardan nickler
dini nickler
nefret nickleri
nickler
rap nickleri
webmaster
backlink
kaiser_dealxa
wordpress temaları
pagerank
seo
msn nickleri
romantik nickler
yalnızlık nickleri
yazılı msn avatarları
yeni msn nickler

dantel örgü modelleri
dantel oya modelleri
webmaster
alexa
supremacyshowtime
aşk nickleri
bebek nickleri
msn avatarları
webmaster
Kahraman Türkler
civciv
hayalbahcesi
Msn Nickleri
msn ifadeleri
Msn Nickleri
Msn Nickleri
msn nickleri
toddplivingston
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
basketbol
borsa
haberler
spor
müzik
iç haberler
futbol
yusuf
yusuf
yusuf
leylek
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
health articles
gafoloji
warez



[code]Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
webmaster[/code][code]
Kahraman Türkler[/code][code]
civciv[/code][code]
hayalbahcesi[/code][code]
Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
msn ifadeleri[/code][code]
Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code][code]
toddplivingston[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code]
[code]
msn nickleri[/code]
[code]
basketbol[/code]
[code]
borsa[/code]
[code]
dış haberler[/code]
[code]
futbol[/code]
[code]
haberler[/code]
[code]
iç haberler[/code]
[code]
müzik[/code]
[code]
spor[/code]
[code]
voleybol[/code]
[code]
tarih[/code]
[code]
teknoloji[/code]
[code]
blogger themes[/code]
[code]
blogy navideno themes[/code]
[code]
msn nickleri[/code]
[code]
darlehen[/code]
[code]
health articles[/code]
[code]
grup hepsi[/code]


"iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması"

Msn avatarları


"iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması"

"iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması"

msn

hayalbahcesi
forum merkezi
muhabbet
oyun merkezi
genel bilgiler
-
hayalbahcesi

hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
forum
komik
msn avatarları
tsubasa
vbulletin
aşk
sevgi
msn nickleri

Andreya said...

Hi Nice Blog . seo school helps in building a rank and keeping a site on top. In order to optimise a blogging site or anything for that matter of fact, you need to have the right content in place.

www.nickler.gen.tr said...

onlarca kategoride yüzlerce msn nickleri, msn live, sohbet, yabancı müzik imkanı ve çok daha fazlası...

msn nickleri,emo nickleri, nickler,

Sinan said...

Thanks so much for this! This is exactly what I was looking for bedava chat - sohbet odaları - sohbet - islami chat - sohbet siteleri - mynet sohbet - garanti arkadaş - islami sohbet - mirc sohbet - sohbet indir - mirc script indir - bedava sohbet - - sohbet odaları - cinsel muhabbet - dini sohbet - gay sohbet - cinsel sohbet - seviyeli sohbet - porno sohbet - kameralı sohbet - cinsellik sohbet - sex chat - mirc - mirc indir - kamerali mirc - turkce mirc - sohbet siteleri - cet - Video izle - sohbet - Muhabbet - sohbet siteleri - kızlarla sohbet

King Bayern Munich said...

This is a great article, supplies the useful information for me, thanks in this
pressure relief valve|forged Steel valve|butterfly valves|dustbin

King Bayern Munich said...

This is a great article, supplies the useful information for me, thanks in this
pressure relief valve|forged Steel valve|butterfly valves|dustbin

King Bayern Munich said...

This is a great article, supplies the useful information for me, thanks in this
soft sofa
Modern-stone-sculpture
billiards
Long span shelving
oil paintings
outdoor ceramic tiles
casual shoes
oil paintings

youlacka said...

That is really very good article.Thanks! kizlarla chatcetseviyeli sohbetchat odalarisohbet odalarisohbet odalari

dell laptop batteries said...

laptop batteries
Dell Laptop Batteries
HP Laptop Batteries
Apple Laptop Batteries
IBM Laptop Batteries
Sony Laptop Batteries
Compaq Laptop Batteries
Acer Laptop Batteries
toshiba-laptop-batteries
Lenovo Laptop Batteries

luck said...

Nike Air Max Shoes unique style and pattern gain very popuplarity from people. This may be the most memorable Air Max generations to see, the weight of the color of the predecessor of the loan, the Nike Air Max Wildwood Supreme Classic weight.All of the characteristics decide thatNike Air Max turbulenc are durable , smooth , very good to use for the sports events.Nike Shoes Us are identified as the plan colors , just like white , black , and so on. The popular of Nike Air Max Shoes is mainly due to the black color is perfect and rounded material layer.

Nike Mercurial Vapor Superfly said...

Ah good exciting content! Will always come to our attention. To bring you good news-works perfect! Nike Football Cleats best shoes 2011!! And Nike Mercurial Vapor Superfly.Nike soccer cleats with New nike soccer shoes or Nike mercurial soccer cleats .

steroids pharmacy said...

Wonderfully interesting blog post thanks for writing it i just added your blog to my bookmarks and will check back often.

uğur Aksu said...

Very informative and trustworthy blog. Please keep updating with great posts like this one.

sohbet net - cinsel sohbet - çet sohbet - sohbetci - adana sohbet - kerizim - sohbet odalari - chat odalari - cinsellik sohbet

China tours said...

That is really cool. Thanks for finding it. Some really good ideas there, this is going to be a real time sink. I am a china tour lover,You can learn more: China tour operator | China tour packages | China city travel

jaring pengaman said...

Thanks for sharing nice information with us
jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung
http://www.agen-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.toko-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.pusat-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://jualjaringpengaman.blogspot.com/
https://pancasamudera.wordpress.com/
https://pasangjaringfutsal.wordpress.com/
https://jualtambangmurah.wordpress.com/
https://tokojaring.wordpress.com/
https://jualjaringfutsal.wordpress.com/
https://jaringfutsal.wordpress.com/

Learn Chinese said...

The best place to study Chinese online is in China. However, we understand that it isn't always possible to move here to study Chinese language. The next best thing is to study with our experienced teachers in a virtual classroom. Online students enjoy the same excellent way of Mandarin Online Course and custom designed courseware that we provide for our face to face clients.



Methenolone acetate said...

Great Post - just keep doing Your Job and all will be fine ...
Aslo come to my site Steroids online store