What I wrote at Lib Dem Voice

June 14, 2007

That Broon meme

With thanks to James Graham for 'tagging' me (why is the 'blogosphere' so afflicted with such infantilising terms?):

2 things of which Gordon Brown should be proud.
  1. Giving independence to the Bank of England.
  2. Having been on watch during a broadly benign economic cycle.
2 things for which he should apologise.
  1. Bank-rolling the Iraq war without a murmur of dissent.
  2. An obsession with centralization, targets and complexity which has undermined public services and made the lives of the poor much harder.
2 things that he should do immediately when he becomes PM.
  1. Introduce fair votes for all local and national elections in the UK.
  2. Scrap ID Cards, and strengthen Freedom of Information.
2 things he should do while he is PM.
  1. Oversee a comprehensive decentralization to local communities of power over public services and the taxation necessary to pay for them.
  2. Vigorously oppose protectionist interests wherever they exist, and unashamedly press for free and fair world trade as the best means of lifting the poorest out of poverty.
My turn to tag: Jonathan Calder, Cicero, Alex Wilcock, Andy Mayer, David Rundle, and Liberal Review.

9 comments:

Nathaniel Tapley said...

I, oddly, agree with almost everything in this post. Everything, that is, except for the conceptually-muddled and intellectually fraudulent final point.

Trade, by definition cannot, except accidentally, be both 'free' and 'fair'. If it is 'free' it must be entirely free from governmental control. If we are to ensure that it is 'fair' (given the general understanding of the term 'fair trade' - payment of more than the market suggests is necessary for goods) we accept that the market does not do this on its own.

Free trade is not fair trade. Free trade is the way of distributing commodities with the greatest possible efficiency and responsiveness to the needs of those with the capital necessary to purchase those commodities. This is, at its very essence, not fair to those who are involved in 'inefficient' industries. A government cannot promote both 'free' and 'fair' trade.

We can see some of the benefits of removing all tariff protection from an economy in the first large economy to do so: Iraq. Interim Order 12 of the Iraqi Provisional Authority removed all tariff protection from all of Iraq's industries (a key plank in Grover Norquist's economic plans for Iraq). Within a year, unemployment had risen to 60%, as local industries went bankrupt.

One wonders why those Hayek-hounds who believe that we should have no tariffs on trade; a minimal, flat income tax only use to provide security services; a robust, armed populace; privatised public services are not all moving to Iraq, where they can find all of these things...

Stephen Tall said...

I wasn't meaning 'fair trade' in that market-distorting sense - rather that the conditions of trade should be fair so all countries can participate on a level playing field.

Matt Sellwood said...

Stephen,

An interesting technique - you bookmarked all your excellent points with a first and last point with which I virulently disagree.

My emotions reading that piece were 'oh bloody Stephen...oh, hang on, some of this is quite good...hmm, I agree with that too...oh BLOODY HELL!'

:)

Best as ever,

Matt

Stephen Tall said...

It's called triangulation, Matt ;)

neil craig said...

I was going to make the same point about "fair" trade. I spoke against converting LibDem policy fronm the traditional one of Free Trade to having some international body to regulate "fiar trade" policies designed to keep commodity prices up by prevent upcoming countries undercutting established markets.

http://a-place-to-stand.blogspot.com/2005/10/fairtrade-scot-lib-dem-motion.html

Shortly thereafter i was expelled from the party on the gounds thattraditional liberal principles are now redefined as "illiberal" - or alternately that the party can no longer honestly be called Liberal.

Julian H said...

I'm unsure as to whether the point even warrants a response, but nonetheless - regarding Hayek and Iraq (possibly even more tenuous than Iraq and European Monetary Union), liberals believe in a balanced environment in which all people's views are tolerated and have a chance to operate in the political sphere, thus creating a stable framework for free trade and free thought to thrive. Iraq was raped by a despotic murderous thieving lunatic before being plunged into anarchic tribal civil war by foreign forces (a campaign not supported by liberals) - I'd have thought even the most ardent Marx-Hound would acknowledge that these are the cause of its problems, rather than free trade and low income tax.

I'll quote Hobhouse (why not eh?):

"The heart of Liberalism is understanding that progress is not a matter of mechanical contrivance [JH adds: like so-called Fair Trade schemes], but of liberation of living spiritual energy. Good mechanism is that which provides the channels wherein such energy can flow unimpeded"

Dan T. said...

re: free & fair
I disagree that freedom and fairness are mutually exclusive terms - it is only an insistence on an absolutist or theoretically purist position which says so.

For me liberal (and therefore also Liberal) has always meant a living, breathing freedom from dogma, which requires constant moderation and balance between the competing extremes, applied as and when and where relevant and practical.

So the idea of 'free & fair' is a positive challenge, not a static, stultifyingly doctrinaire position of ideological 'free or fair' smugness.

It is one of the tragedies of the age that the language of philosophic conception has been degraded by uniformly applied standardization of logical terminology, particularly how such a misleadingly simple oxymoron as 'extreme liberal' sends so many sensible people into sweats of dizzying confusion with outbreaks of panicky and unprincipled irrationality.

The main (and best) criticism of sham-liberal politics is incoherence, which is what leads to it's collapse.

To reestablish our majoritarian appeal we need to reclaim our identity in the popular mind and escape the divisive polarizing tendency of linguistic innuendo - to do so will show we are prepared to govern, and govern well.

The spin-meisters of the current regime misunderstood this rule, and are being unravelled by their dishonesty in pretending to be all things to all people while simultaneously proving how equal a game of dice really is.

Anonymous said...

msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
şekilli msn nickleri
şekilli nickler
güzel msn nickleri
frmtr
msn nickleri
.
.
.

wp themes
blogger templates
wordpress temaları
wordpress themes
wp themes
wordpress temaları
blogger templates
wp themes
blogger themes
blogger templates


erken rezervasyon
129.93.251.82
free link directory
e-directorylive
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
test atölyesi
testatölyesi
test atölyesi
testatölyesi
Msn Nickleri
free warez
Msn avatarları
free wordpress templates
free wordpress themes
free wp themes
free wp themes
free wp templates
blogger tips template
blogger template
blogger themes
free blogger templates
free blogger themes
wordpress templates
blogger templates

sandbox
msn nickleri
webmaster
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
dmoz
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
msn nickleri
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması

dmoz
alexa
kaiser_dealxa
seo uzmanı
seo
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması



msn nickleri
msn nickleri
freewaresmania
msn nickleri
msn
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
todd livingston
aşk şiirleri
aşk şiirleri
haberler
msn nickleri
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
e-okul
health articles
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
credito
pret
msn nicknames
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
hilary duff
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon
ramazan ayı
msn nickleri
msn spitznamen
msn nickleri
hayal bahçesi
şarkı sözleri
seo yarışması
msn nickleri
gafoloji
msn nickleri
msn nickleri


msn nickleri
tsubasa
ev dekorasyon

msn nickleri

yeni msn nickleri

msn avatarları

komik msn nickleri

delikanlı msn nickleri

güzel msn avatarları

şekilli msn nickleri

msn avatarları

beşiktaş nickleri
aşk sevgi nickleri
duygusal msn nickleri
damardan nickler
dini nickler
nefret nickleri
nickler
rap nickleri
webmaster
backlink
kaiser_dealxa
wordpress temaları
pagerank
seo
msn nickleri
romantik nickler
yalnızlık nickleri
yazılı msn avatarları
yeni msn nickler

dantel örgü modelleri
dantel oya modelleri
webmaster
alexa
supremacyshowtime
aşk nickleri
bebek nickleri
msn avatarları
webmaster
Kahraman Türkler
civciv
hayalbahcesi
Msn Nickleri
msn ifadeleri
Msn Nickleri
Msn Nickleri
msn nickleri
toddplivingston
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
basketbol
borsa
haberler
spor
müzik
iç haberler
futbol
yusuf
yusuf
yusuf
leylek
msn nickleri
msn nickleri
health articles
gafoloji
warez



[code]Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
webmaster[/code][code]
Kahraman Türkler[/code][code]
civciv[/code][code]
hayalbahcesi[/code][code]
Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
msn ifadeleri[/code][code]
Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
Msn Nickleri[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code][code]
toddplivingston[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code][code]
msn nickleri[/code]
[code]
msn nickleri[/code]
[code]
basketbol[/code]
[code]
borsa[/code]
[code]
dış haberler[/code]
[code]
futbol[/code]
[code]
haberler[/code]
[code]
iç haberler[/code]
[code]
müzik[/code]
[code]
spor[/code]
[code]
voleybol[/code]
[code]
tarih[/code]
[code]
teknoloji[/code]
[code]
blogger themes[/code]
[code]
blogy navideno themes[/code]
[code]
msn nickleri[/code]
[code]
darlehen[/code]
[code]
health articles[/code]
[code]
grup hepsi[/code]


"iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması"

Msn avatarları


"iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması"

"iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması"

msn

hayalbahcesi
forum merkezi
muhabbet
oyun merkezi
genel bilgiler
-
hayalbahcesi

hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
hayalbahcesi
forum
komik
msn avatarları
tsubasa
vbulletin
aşk
sevgi
msn nickleri

www.nickler.gen.tr said...

onlarca kategoride yüzlerce msn nickleri, msn live, sohbet, yabancı müzik imkanı ve çok daha fazlası...

msn nickleri,emo nickleri, nickler,